Fantasy Maps: Better Bus Coverage

After fun with rail, I tried to get practical for my next fantasy map.  Throughout 2004 and much of 2005 I created and edited this bus map.  The focus was on more comprehensive regional coverage, but also faster travel speeds.  I extended local services to places like Polaris, Tuttle  Crossing, Canal Winchester, and Smoky Row Road.  I changed express routes to keep them on the freeway and off the surface streets as much as possible with the goal of reducing travel times.  I created lots more crosstown routes to create something closer to a grid bus network, and also several community circulator “link” routes.

Notice that you can see every stop on the system map.  That means more longer walks to bus stops, but faster in-vehicle travel times.  I still believe improving travel times is critical to improve COTA ridership by coming closer to competing with cars.

I was still using Microsoft Paint to draw my maps, but the system map was clickable.  Clicking on a line would take the user to an individual route maps for the route.  I will try to post a full version of this plan on a separate web-site soon.

Example of a route map for the #4:

In downtown, I eliminated the High Street line-up and created a system that would have some local routes looping around downtown clockwise and some counter-clockwise. My goal was to expand transit access in more of downtown.  I also couldn’t resist adding in a couple of streetcar lines linking downtown to the inner neighborhoods on all four sides.

Fantasy Map: Seattle-Style Transit for Columbus

After my first fantasy map for a comprehensive subway and regional rail system in Columbus, I moved on to different, but still overly-ambitious, plans.  I created the following maps in May, 2004:

Regional Map

Downtown Detail Map

My plan included the following elements:

  • Relocate I-70 – One alternative considered for ODOT’s I-70/I-71 South Innerbelt Corridor Study was to relocate I-70 south to OH-104 on the south side.  ODOT dismissed this alternative, but I always liked it because of the opportunities it would create to improve the connection between downtown and German Village, and to use the existing right-of-way for something else.
  • Re-route I-71 – My plan called for a similar treatment for I-71 on the east side.  It would be reconnected to the neighborhood by re-routing the I-71 to the existing OH-315 on the west side and the relatively new I-670 on the north edge of downtown.  The obvious problem with this plan is that it creates a new split on the north side instead of the existing split on the south side.  As an alternative, I-71 (and I-70 for that matter) could be routed around the I-270 outerbelt.
  • Construct a downtown subway/busway in the existing I-70/I-71 trench – There are generally two ways to build a subway; cut and cover, or tunnel.  Cut and cover is usually less expensive for a shallow depth, but it is very disruptive to the residents and businesses on a street.  In the case of the downtown innerbelt though, the cut phase is already done.  I took advantage of this by drawing two short subway lines. The innerbelt line (green) connects from a freight track just north of Fort Hayes to Glenwood Avenue in Franklinton. The eastside line (red) along the old I-70 right of way allows transfers to the innerbelt line at 4th St. A new subway line tunneled underneath High Street would allow a connection to a new Arena District inter-city rail terminal.  Short subway lines like this usually aren’t very useful, but I planned to integrate the rail with a comprehensive express bus system from around the region that would use some of the same subway tunnels for transfers.  Stations for the subways would be double-platformed, with rail on the inside and two bus lanes on the outside “tracks.”  Exclusive ramps would allow busses to access the downtown busway tunnel from all connecting freeways.  This system was inspired by a trip to Seattle in August, 2003, where I saw how well their downtown busway tunnel was integrated with regional express buses.
  • Commuter Rail – My plan included four regional commuter rail lines going from downtown to Delaware, Newark, Lancaster, and Washington Courthouse
  • Morse-Bethel BRT – This is a carry-over from the first fantasy map.  I envisioned exclusive median lanes with a new tunnel or bridge to connect Morse and Bethel roads over the Olentangy River. Easton, Tuttle Crossing, and a transfer to the commuter rail would be served.
  • Streetcars – My downtown detail map shows free streetcars operating as one-way couplets on 3rd/4th, Spring/Long, and Town/Rich.  My goal was to stimulate development in Columbus’ inner neighborhoods.  This was inspired by a trip to Portland in May, 2004, where I observed their downtown streetcar.
  • New Subways – If all this stuff was really built, then you start to have some real economies of scale to extend the subway system, particularly to the north along High Street.  I included some dashed lines to show subway extension ideas.

All in all, it’s another unrealistic plan, but I think it really is about the appropriate scale system that a city the size of Columbus should have.  We’re just not investing that kind of money into transit in this country right now, so we have to get more creative to serve people with less money.

Fantasy Map: New York-Style Transit for Columbus

Below is the first fantasy map that I dreamed up for rapid transit in Columbus in 2002, created using Microsoft Paint.

Columbus Rail Transit PlanRegional Map

Downtown Detail Map

The map includes:

  • Four major subway lines on Columbus’ densest urban, commercial streets.
    • High St – Red Line
    • Cleveland Ave – Green Line
    • W. Broad St – Orange Line
    • Livingston/East Main St – Purple Line
    • The three lines other than the High Street Red Line form a loop around downtown, inspired by Chicago.
  • Four light rail or commuter rail lines going from downtown to:
    • Delaware via the CSX tracks on West Campus
    • Grove City
    • Lancaster
    • Port Columbus
  • One east-west bus rapid transit (BRT) corridor connecting Morse Road and Bethel Road with a tunnel or a bridge
  • High speed rail to Cleveland and Dayton/Cincinnati

I think I started this shortly after a trip to New York City in September, 2001.  Until then, the biggest city I had ever visited was Cleveland, and I think I had only ridden the Rapid there once.  It’s easy for a transportation engineer to be amazed and inspired by the comprehensive and frequent subway network that gives New Yorkers an alternative to either cars or buses sitting in traffic.   Of course, the subway works in New York because of the extremely high population and employment densities.  This is something that Columbus doesn’t have and I recognized at the time that this map was just a dream.  I quickly moved onto more practical plans, which I hope to share with you soon.

New Site, New Name

Google recently eliminated it’s Page Creator site and replaced it with Google Sites.  I haven’t been happy with the way my Columbus Bus Plan site transferred over to the new site, and the Google Analytics tracking code also stopped working.  These are problems I could probably fix if I made the effort, but I’ve previously considered starting fresh anyway and this gives me a good excuse.  Transport for Columbus will be my new site.  Other than the reasons mentioned above, reasons for the change include the following:

1. New Name – The Columbus Bus Plan was too mode-specific.  After all, my whole concept for a bus plan originated with fantasy subway rail maps.  The new name will allow me to comment on all forms of transport, even cars.  The Transport for Columbusname has obviously been inspired by TfL, which deals with all modes of transport for London.

2. User Interaction – I love hearing feedback and opinions from people who have stumbled upon my site.  Changing the site from a web page more of a blog via WordPress will make it easy for people to leave comments.

3. Segmentation – Most people don’t have the time – or probably the interest – to look over all my ideas at once.  This will allow readers to see specific ideas in short posts instead of having to navigate through the web site.

With that, I look forward to moving my previous content over to the new format and working on the design of the new page, which is currently the default WordPress template.  I hope to hear from you soon.